Beneath the streets of Smithtown lies a maximum-security penitentiary, built to contain the most violent and notorious criminals in history. For decades, whispers of riots, failed experiments, and disappearances have haunted the town. Now, the prison’s gates are open—and you’re invited inside.
Step into a terrifying walk-through haunt where each cell block, interrogation chamber, and execution hall tells a story darker than the last. From the creators of Nightmare on Main Street and brought to life by the legendary Abracadabra NYC, this is more than a haunted house—it’s an immersive horror experience that will test your nerves at every turn.
Escape from the Penitentiary runs:
October 10 – November 2, 2025
Thursdays, Fridays & Saturdays
7:00 PM – 11:00 PM
Tickets are sold in 1-hour entry windows:
7:00 – 8:00 PM
8:00 – 9:00 PM
9:00 – 10:00 PM
10:00 – 11:00 PM
Each ticket includes:
One terrifying penitentiary walkthrough
One complimentary spooky cocktail at Bull Smith’s Tavern
Valet parking included
Warning: This experience is designed to scare. Enter at your own risk.
-
Escape from the Penitentiary is located outside Bull Smith’s Tavern at 155 W. Main Street in Smithtown, NY.
-
The haunt runs from October 10 – November 2, open Thursdays, Fridays & Saturdays from 7:00 PM – 11:00 PM.
-
Tickets are $40 per person and include a full penitentiary tour plus a spooky cocktail at Bull Smith’s Tavern.
-
Tickets are sold in 1-hour time slots (7–8 PM, 8–9 PM, 9–10 PM, 10–11 PM). Your ticket guarantees entry within your chosen hour.
-
Yes! Valet parking is provided for all haunt guests and Bull Smith’s Tavern visitors during the event.
-
Yes! After your tour, enjoy your included spooky cocktail at Bull Smith’s Tavern—and stick around for food, drinks, and live energy all night long.
-
Highly recommended! Time slots are limited and will sell out quickly.
-
Tickets will ONLY be sold through Posh.VIP and no other third-party ticketing systems.